News Reader.info

All personal laws must be codified under a uniform national law in keeping with the true spirit of secularism

The men and women who wrote our Constitution 67 years ago had a clearer idea of secularism than most political leaders do today. To them, secularism meant equal treatment for all religions,

preferential treatment for none.

Separate personal religious laws violate this civilised definition of secularism. Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar said as far back as in March 1947, when the Constituent Assembly had begun a

preliminary drafting of the Constitution, that all citizens should have the right “to claim full and equal benefit of all laws and proceedings for the security of persons and property as is

enjoyed by other subjects regardless of any usage or custom based on religion and be subject to like punishment, pains and penalties and to none other.”

In short, all personal laws — Hindu, Muslim, Sikh and others — must be codified under a uniform national law. The argument for ‘one nation, one law’ dates back to several months before

Independence. As the Constituent Assembly began deliberating on this contentious issue, the Fundamental Rights Committee made a strong pitch for superseding archaic personal laws, some based

on the Sharia, others on antiquated Hindu practices.

Ambedkar and his colleagues in the drafting committee received immediate opposition from Muslims. Hindus and Parsis were more sanguine. The distinguished Parsi libertarian Minoo Masani, a

member of the Fundamental Rights Committee, wrote that it was the State’s duty to replace personal religious laws with a universal common code. His colleague on the committee, Kanhaiyalal

Munshi, another distinguished lawyer and conservative Hindu leader (who today would be called a Hindutvawadi by ignorant journalists), was even more robust in advocating uniform personal

laws for all religions, including Hinduism. He said, “No civil or criminal court shall, in adjudicating any matter or executing any order, recognise any custom or usage imposing any civil

disability on any person on the ground of his caste, status, religion, race or language.”

Muslim objections, led by Mohammad Ali Jinnah (a Shia Khoja who drank Scotch, ate pork, and never prayed), were endorsed by Jawaharlal Nehru who bought Jinnah’s argument of ‘the dangers of a

Hindu Raj’ if Muslim personal law was interfered with. As a result, Ambedkar, Masani and Munshi’s draft on superseding personal religious laws was made voluntary and non-enforceable.

Secularism tasted its first defeat literally days after Independence on August 25, 1947, when this report, making universal personal religious laws voluntary, was submitted to the

Constituent Assembly. Mahboob Ali Baig, a member of the assembly, warned darkly, “This contract is enjoined on the Mussalmans by the Quran, and if it is not followed, a marriage is not legal

at all. For 1,350 years this law has been practised by Muslims and recognised by all authorities in all states. If today some other method of proving marriage is going to be introduced, we

refuse to abide by it because it is not according to our religion. It is not according to the code laid down for us for all times.”

Nehru gave in quickly. Jinnah had undermined Nehru’s confidence to such an extent that the future prime minister did not even heed Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel’s advice to stay the course. In

the 1950s, parts of Hindu personal law were eventually codified, modernised and gender discrimination removed. But Muslim personal law remains stuck in the medieval Middle East of 1,350

years ago that Mahboob Ali Baig rigidly wanted Muslims to adhere to.

Seventy years after Independence, the debate on UCC has reached a decisive moment. The Supreme Court’s judgement outlawing instant triple talaq (talaq-e-bidat) is a small step towards reform

in Muslim personal law.

However, then-Chief Justice JS Khehar made a strange observation in his dissenting order, days before retiring, by placing talaq-e-bidat outside the purview of fundamental rights guaranteed

in Part III of the Constitution. Justice Khehar’s minority dissenting judgement argued, “Religion is a matter of faith, and not of logic. It is not open to a court to accept an egalitarian

approach over a practice which constitutes an integral part of religion. We cannot accept the petitioners’ claim, because the challenge raised is in respect of an issue of ‘personal law’

which has constitutional protection.”

This was triumphantly seized upon by the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) to claim its medieval belief that Sharia supersedes the Constitution on Muslim personal laws.

Nonetheless, the momentum for UCC is building. The Law Commission has speeded up compiling public opinion on a uniform civil code. It will submit its report to the government for legislative

action. The AIMPLB will contest UCC fiercely. It has always opposed Muslim reform. Only by keeping their flock blind can the one-eyed continue to exercise power over their benighted

fiefdom.

The writer is author of The New Clash of Civilizations: How The Contest Between America, China, India and Islam Will Shape Our Century

Meet actress whose kanyadaan was performed by Vijay Mallya, she quit acting despite working with superstars, her husband is..., name is..

MS Dhoni opens up for FIRST time after being inducted into ICC Hall of Fame, former India captain says, ' It is something that I will...'

Meet world's most unknown tribe, cannibals who live in..., met humans after 55,000 years, they are from..., are called..

Bankrupt Pakistan in big trouble, price of this animal is rising massively, there is a China connection, it is...

This is Uttar Pradesh richest district with only 7 percent poor population, not Noida, Lucknow, Kanpur, it is...

Kangana Ranaut reacts to Raja Raghuvanshi's murder on honeymoon in Meghalaya, calls Sonam Raghuvanshi ‘biggest...’

'Bigger destruction than Corona', US expert issues chilling warning regarding China

Indore honeymoon murder case: Sonam, Raj met through a piece of paper, story behind their wedding, honeymoon revealed

This man, Lata Mangeshkar and Kishore Kumar's guru, who launched their careers, died in poverty, his wife was found begging at..., his name is..

Viral video: Groom's electrifying dance to Bollywood hit 'Dhoom Machale' steals show at wedding, even Hrithik Roshan could not stop himself from commenting

BTS' RM, V officially complete military service, confirm concert 'real soon'

Meet actress whose German great-grandfather fought against Hitler, her mother was expelled; she is now top Indian...

India's 'first car' was made in Kerala, not the famous Hindustan Ambassador, was designed by..., name was...

Shah Rukh Khan, Salman Khan's Tiger Vs Pathaan on hold due to Ranbir Kapoor's Dhoom 4? Here's what we know

Anil Ambani's company surpasses Mukesh Ambani to become first private Indian firm to develop..., to invest Rs 50000000000 in...

This is the only city in the world where non-veg food is banned, even tourists are not allowed to bring, it is located in...

Pakistan, China in fear as India plans to test advanced hypersonic missile developed under 'Project Vishnu', its top speed is..., name is...

Housefull 5 box office collection day 4: Akshay Kumar, Riteish Deshmukh, Abhishek Bachchan-starrer sees 60% drop but crosses Rs 100 crore in India, earns Rs...

This actor, once India’s richest superstar, owned 7 cars, 25-room bungalow, then lost everything, lived in chawl, died in poverty due to..., name is..

Modi govt isn't ending ties with Pakistan's friend Turkey due to this reason, a complete ban could harm...

Amol Parashar breaks silence on dating rumours with Konkana Sen Sharma: 'Naming every relation is...'

Bad news for Pakistan, China, Indian Army to get Rs 30000 crore air defence missile system, has the capability to..., its name is...

This Indian ‘Missile Bus’, developed by DRDO, can become nightmare for Pakistan and China, it has a rage of 5800km, it can carry…, it's name is..

Weather update: Delhi-NCR witness scorching heat as temperature rises to 43.4 degrees Celsius, IMD predicts light rainfall on...

Donald Trump authorises additional 2000 National Guard members to Los Angeles as anti-immigration protests escalate, here's what we know so far

Meet man who is IIT dropout, now leads global tech company worth Rs 1026050000000, he works for...

Billionaires in this country hit Rs 5.17 lakh crore in total wealth, while common people struggle with...

'Mehendi wali baith ja zara!': Man slams train's AC coach experience after 'baraati family' create chaos, calls it 'worst...'

Meet woman, daughter of IPS officer, who cracked UPSC in second attempt without coaching, her AIR is..., now posted in...

Apple launches iOS 26, boosts iPhone experience: 5 things to know

WWDC 2025: Apple unveils new software design 'Liquid Glass' for iOS, macOS and others; check here

Director Manish Gupta denies allegations of stabbing driver: 'This is an extortion racket'

Gurdas Maan's younger brother Gurpanth Maan dies after brief illness in Mohali

Meet man who started working at 14 as vegetable cutter, later opened restaurant in US, now he’s famous for his...

Aamir Khan addresses 23 year age gap with Genelia D'Souza in Sitaare Zameen Par: 'That thought did come to me but...'

SSC CGL Notification 2025 Out: Check dates, posts, eligibility, direct link and more

MS Dhoni fans on cloud nine as ICC inducts him in 2025 Hall of Fame: Check full list of inductees

Elon Musk's Starlink required to share users' data with Indian govt after concerns of...; info will include

Meet Muslim actress, who married Hindu producer, follows both Hinduism and Islam, flopped in Bollywood, name is...

Days after Operation Sindoor, Pakistan plans to buy J-35 5th-gen fighter jets from...; not US, Russia, Turkey, it is...

Steve Jobs taught Apple CEO Tim Cook a skill that few people have: ‘Never get...’

Meet India's youngest CEO, who started coding at 5, developed 1st app at 9, later started his company at 13, now he runs...

Axiom-4 mission launch postponed again due to...; new liftoff now scheduled for...

Fatwa was issued against writer Salman Rushdie, now Iranian rapper faces death sentence for...

Bengaluru shocker: Techie stabs 36-year-old married girlfriend 17 times, arrested

Infosys' Narayana Murthy, Sudha Murty, Zerodha's Nikhil Kamath own flat in this luxurious tower, check it's Vijay Mallya connection, it is worth Rs...

Viral Video: Indian student pinned to ground, handcuffed, deported from US

Iran extends ban on walking dogs in public, violators to be punished by...

Axiom-4 mission: Indian astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla completes final launch drill, calls Ax-4 journey 'much larger than...'

Khushi Kapoor-Vedang Raina's intense conversation caught on camera, netizens slam paps for privacy intrusion: 'Give them...'

Al Pacino reveals he declined Star Wars film due to this shocking reason: 'They offered me a fortune but...'

Meghalaya honeymoon murder: What is Raghuwanshi App, through which Raja and Sonam met?

Fedlan Kılıçaslan on Tariffs: The Painful Reset Reshaping the Global Economy By Andrzej Kozioł

Elvish Yadav cuts ties with Prince Narula after bitter feud on Roadies XX: 'Don't want to talk to him in future'

World’s richest dog, who travels the world, 27 employees work for him, had mansion bought from popstar, not Mukesh Ambani, Nita Ambani's pet dog, net worth is Rs...

Amitabh Bachchan shuts down trolls asking him to sleep on time, saying 'umar ho gayi aapki': 'Mere maran ki...'

Rupali Ganguly slams those who kept mum during Operation Sindoor: 'If you haven’t...'

Cosmic kiss: Moon to meet these planets in rare conjunctions in June with stellar night sky views, know when, where, how to see

Made in Rs 35 crore, this Ranbir Kapoor film earned Rs 175 crore, was accused of plagiarism, sent as India's entry to Oscars but...

The Science Behind Pinnacle AbilityScore: India’s Patented 0–1000 Universal Child Development Metric Transforming Autism, Speech, ABA, Occupational & Developmental Therapies Worldwide!

Elon Musk-owned Starlink to start service in India in..., you will have to pay every month...

OYO founder Ritesh Agarwal seeks public help for THIS small task, offers Rs 3 lakh prize

China's 'water bomb' tickling, India faces catastrophe in 'water war' with Beijing, details here

Testosterone Cypionate FAQ, Uses, Benefits, and Where to Buy

Who is Sashidhar Jagdishan? He leads India's largest private bank worth Rs 1515854 crore, now facing financial fraud allegations

Narayana's Relentless Triumph: Fulfilling JEE Dreams in JEE Advance 2025 exams

SSC CGL 2025 Notification to be released today at ssc.gov.in: Registration to begin...; exams from THIS date

These Indian breakfast dishes ranked among world's best, not samosa, dosa, idli, these are...

Mukesh Ambani gets richer by Rs 30786 crore after Reliance earns Rs...; net worth climbed to...

Ravichandran Ashwin loses his cool at female umpire, slams bat after being given LBW in TNPL 2025 | Watch viral video

Amid job cuts, THIS company freezes 2025 hiring budget for..., not Google, Infosys, Wipro, it is...

Jamsetji Tata donated land for this institute, which started with just 24 students, CV Raman was one of directors, it is...

Thug Life box office collection day 4: Kamal Haasan, Mani Ratnam film drops further, earns just Rs 37 crore in opening weekend

BCCI announces BIG change in venues for Team India's home series against South Africa, West Indies: See updated schedule

Big move by Sunil Mittal as Bharti Airtel inks multi-year pact with this Swedish firm for...

India records sharp decline in poverty, Pakistan continues to..., number of poor population...

42% of Pakistanis live in abject poverty, more may become poor if India continues with decision on Indus Waters Treaty

Cristiano Ronaldo drops major hint on his future after leading Portugal to 2nd UEFA Nations League title, confirms he will play at...

Another masterstroke by Anil Ambani, set to enter this sector, to target Rs 5000 crore market, it is..., aims to...

Partho Ghosh, director of Agni Sakshi, dies of heart attack at 75

SSC GD Constable 2025: When and where to download Constable merit list online, details here

Ektaa Kapoor calls Anurag Kashyap 'dumb' after he mocks saas-bahu dramas: 'You are so...'

Protest in Los Angeles: How many illegal migrants live in US? How many of them are Indians?

'Selfie yacht of 'celebrities' safely making its way to shores of Israel': IDF intercepts boat carrying Swedish climate activist Greta Thunberg on its way to Gaza

'There are 3...': Paresh Rawal reacts after fans requests him to return to Akshay Kumar's Hera Pheri 3

Who is Rima Hassan? French-Palestinian MP accompanying Greta Thunberg on Gaza-bound ship intercepted by Israel, was born in this Muslim country...

UPSC CSE Prelims Result 2025 to be declared soon at upsc.gov.in, Know when, where to download scorecards online

This Muslim country has banned people from walking dogs in public, reason will leave you shocked, not Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, UAE, Saudi Arabia, Indonesia, it is...

This is world's largest container ship, arrives at THIS seaport, managed by Indian billionaire whose net worth is Rs 5792310450, not located in US, Russia, China

Navjot Singh Sidhu returns to The Great Indian Kapil Show, Archana Puran Singh reacts: 'I’m coming home...'

Heatwave alert issued in Delhi-NCR, IMD predicts temperature will rise by..., in the next...

Apple Event 2025: Check when and where to watch Apple WWDC 2025 keynote in India, USA, Dubai

This Indian genius who worked with IIT, NASA, challenged Einstein's Theory, went missing for years, he died...

Indore honeymoon murder case: Who is Raj Kushwaha, Sonam Raghuvanshi's 'boyfriend', alleged mastermind behind Raja Raghuvanshi's murder in Meghalaya, shocking details reveal...

Indore couple case: Raja Raghuvansi's wife Sonam was found at Varanasi-Ghazipur main road, says UP Police

Gautam Adani draws less salary than his executives, know who tops the list; where do Mukesh Ambani, Sunil Bharti Mittal stand

Mumbai Train Accident: Several passengers travelling towards CSMT fall from excessive crowded train at Mumbra Station

Amid Russia-Ukraine war, this European country is preparing for big conflict, revamps bunkers, tunnels, not UK, France, Portugal, Spain, it is...

Elon Musk's father Errol Musk says son 'made a mistake' opposing US President Donald Trump, blames...

Housefull 5 box office collection day 3: Akshay Kumar-starrer stays strong, to soon enter Rs 100-crore club